The Linda Gage Memorial Award
2001

JUDGES COMMENTS

This is the fifth year the competition has run and has attracted a large number of entries from colleges and universities around the United Kingdom. The brief was to produce a short radio feature that makes creative use of the medium of sound and demonstrates the entrant’s production skills.

The judges are looking for pieces that are well produced. Technically these takes into account editing, mixing, levels and the overall quality of recorded sound. Creative production is important and the use of music and sound effects should add to the piece. Presentation is vital – it should be lively, authoritative and tell the story.

The judges also look for strong editorial content. The story should have a strong cue that grabs the listener’s attention and puts the piece in context, and the actual piece should have a hook at the beginning, a middle and a conclusion. Interviewees should be relevant to the subject.
 

This Year’s Competition
This year’s entries covered a wide range of topics. The judges felt that some key aspects of radio journalism were not fully addressed. These include working out the order for telling the story and expressing ideas concisely.  Some entries forget they were telling a story and others lost sight of who might want to listen (target audience).

The judges thought that entrants were too quick to accept official lines or views. Others forgot the legal requirement of radio for balance and impartiality. Some entrants were not reporting a story on behalf of the listener but the official.

There was some well-researched material and pretty impressive technical standards.

The judges have chosen as the winner of the Linda Gage Memorial Award this year – AGNES KRUGER.  Her entry “Bounce Control” was a good story about the sports bra, well told with a good variation of views.  Technically it was very dynamic with good use of music.  The production was very pacey. It had plenty of energy and humour but was free of clichés. It was well mixed with no presenter links.  A montage that actually works.
 

Nick Hirst/Angus Moorat
July 2001
 

 Return to Home Page